Finding the perfect lipstick can transform your look with just a swipe. Whether you’re after a bold statement or a subtle everyday hue, Maybelline offers a range of lipsticks that have been vetted by beauty experts for their quality, color payoff, and wearability. Discover our top picks for Maybelline lipsticks that will leave your lips looking luscious and feeling fabulous.
7 Best Maybelline Lipsticks for Luscious Lips, Expertly Approved
1. Editor’s Pick: Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink – Exhilarator
Elevate your confidence and make a statement with Maybelline’s Super Stay Matte Ink in Exhilarator. This lipstick offers a bold, intense color that perfectly complements olive and dusky skin tones, as well as those with neutral undertones. Its no-budge, no-fade formula is ideal for any climate, ensuring long-lasting wear while keeping your lips moisturized. Our experts have found it to be exceptionally durable, with no flaking, peeling, or feathering.
Pros:
- Non-streaky application
- Does not settle into lines
- Durable, precise applicator
- Resistant to liquids and grease
- Moisturizing finish
Cons:
- Slightly gooey texture
2. Best Overall: Maybelline Super Stay Vinyl Ink – Peachy Nude
Achieve a natural, captivating finish with the Peachy Nude shade of Maybelline’s Super Stay Vinyl Ink. Its color-locking formula provides 16 hours of wear with a glossy shine, while being resistant to smudging, transfer, and smearing. Priced under $10, it’s a favorite among teens for its affordability and effectiveness. Customers love its quality, with one noting, “It’s the best base layer! I apply a gloss on top & love the outcome! Affordable & effective!”
Pros:
- Instant shine
- Smooth vinyl finish
- Flake-proof
- Potently pigmented color
Cons:
- Slightly sticky
Pro Tip: Shake before application and use micellar water for gentle removal.
3. Best for Chapped Lips: Maybelline Super Stay 24 – Timeless Rose
For a natural rose-colored look that complements no-makeup styles, the Timeless Rose shade from Maybelline Super Stay is perfect. Its lightweight, breathable texture and fade-resistant formula make it suitable for extreme climates, while its moisturizing properties make it ideal for dry, flaky lips.
Pros:
- Quick-drying
- Conditions chapped lips
- Easy application
- Hydrating
Cons:
- Slight tendency to crumble
4. Most Weightless Texture: Maybelline Super Stay Ink Crayon – Reach High
This award-winning crayon lipstick provides a subtle matte finish that complements all skin tones. With its built-in sharpener, it ensures precise application and can also double as a lip liner. It’s a top choice for those who prefer a weightless feel and effortless removal.
Pros:
- Easy to remove
- Hydrates lips
- Non-messy texture
- Weightless
Cons:
- Overpowering smell
5. Best for All Skin Types: Maybelline Color Sensational – On the Mauve
Say goodbye to feathering and bleeding with Maybelline’s Color Sensational Lipstick in On the Mauve. This shade, infused with shea butter, keeps lips hydrated and creamy without settling into lines. It’s travel-friendly and offers a smooth application, making it a favorite among users.
Pros:
- Affordable
- Easy to use
- Melt-proof
- Suits all skin types
Cons:
- Packaging could be improved
6. Best Creamy Finish: Maybelline Matte Finish Color Sensational – Burgundy Blush
Maybelline’s Burgundy Blush offers a creamy matte finish that hides fine lines and wrinkles. This blue-based red shade is versatile and flattering on all skin tones. Its ergonomic twist mechanism makes application easy, while its smear-proof formula ensures longevity across seasons.
Pros:
- One-swipe application
- Creamy, matte finish
- Durable
- Long-lasting
Cons:
- Poor packaging
7. Best Long-Wearing Formula: Maybelline Color Sensational Ultimatte – More Mocha
For a natural, subtle finish that complements all skin tones, try Maybelline’s More Mocha. Its lightweight, blurring formula minimizes the appearance of fine lines, while its quick-drying properties make it suitable for various skin textures. It’s perfect for creating no-makeup and beach looks.
Pros:
- Blurs lip scars
- Good staying power
- Even application
- Comfortable to wear
Cons:
- Could be more moisturizing
How to Choose the Best Maybelline Lipstick
- Ingredients: Look for vegan and cruelty-free options, and check for sulfates, phthalates, parabens, and artificial fragrances. Opt for lipsticks with natural humectants if you have dry lips.
- Texture: Choose a formula that resists flaking, feathering, and smudging for a flawless appearance.
- Skin Type: Select lipsticks that match your skin type—more hydrating options for dry skin and anti-bacterial properties for oily skin.
- Skin Tone and Undertone: Match shades to your skin tone and undertone for a harmonious look. Coral and peach suit fair tones, while blue-based reds enhance medium to olive tones.
How to Apply the Best Maybelline Lipstick
- Exfoliate: Use a lip scrub to remove dead cells and prepare your lips.
- Moisturize: Apply a lip balm and let it absorb to prevent chapping.
- Outline: Use a lip liner to define your lip contours.
- Apply: Apply the lipstick from the cupid’s bow outwards, blot with a tissue, and set with a makeup fixer.
With these expert-approved picks and application tips, your lips will look stunning and feel great all day!
